I am not writing this article from dry theory, but out of deep personal pain and years of hands-on experience in digital ministry.
I recently read a report on a pilot project by AWR (Adventist World Radio) testing the connection between online advertising and local churches. The premise was simple: a digital center gathered requests from people online and passed those contacts along to a local congregation. The outcome was sobering: 31 out of 35 people simply went silent...
Behind that number lies a deep gap into which many of our digital initiatives fall.
The Illusion of Impressive Reports and the Search for a Perpetuum Mobile
In our circles, we have grown accustomed to reporting broad summary figures: "We reached this many people, we handed off this many contacts to churches." Yet any real analyst looking at such reports will tell you they say next to nothing. They fail to answer the critical questions:
Who are these people, and where did they come from?
Which specific ad brought them into the funnel?
How long were they "warmed up," what did they study, and how many lessons did they complete?
What was their actual motivation?
Today, deciding to embark on a spiritual search or join a congregation is harder for people than ever. There is a massive deficit of trust, an ocean of alternatives, and fierce competition for attention—including in the religious sphere.
In the business world, companies spend months nurturing leads: building newsletters, sharing value, and earning trust step by step to prepare someone to make a decision.
Meanwhile, we often try to invent a perpetuum mobile (a perpetual motion machine): gather surface-level cold traffic, distribute contacts to local congregations, and sit back waiting for a miracle—expecting local members to pick them up immediately. When the miracle doesn't happen, we draw conclusions from incomplete data: "Digital evangelism doesn't work." Yet the problem isn't digital; it’s how we build the process.
Three Systemic Reasons Why People Get Lost Along the Way

1. A Broken Chain of Trust
Traffic sources directly determine a person's commitment in subsequent stages. An accidental click on a cold ad is one thing. It is something else entirely when someone first spends time in a library of Bible Q&As or watches a series of videos by a creator they come to trust—and then that very same creator personally invites them to take a course.
In those sequences, the chain of trust remains unbroken. We have seen firsthand how a Bible school branded around a specific influencer achieved a 60–70% completion rate across 20 lessons. That is a remarkable result—completely impossible when working with cold traffic.
2. An Unprepared "Receiving Side"
Learning happens through three mechanics: self-paced, hybrid (AI-assisted), and with a live mentor. Practice consistently proves that learning with a real person retains students exponentially better. A live mentor fosters healthy accountability, keeps the dialogue going, and helps a student get "unstuck" when they hit a wall.
The ideal scenario is when that mentor is part of a local church.
Look at what happens in practice, however: a central office launches ads, collects requests, and drops a contact into an unprepared congregation with a note saying, "Wants to study the Bible."
The local congregation looks at that contact and freezes: "How do we study with them? We were handed a link to some new online school we’ve never even seen ourselves. And what do I do if they ask a tough question?" As a result, the phone call gets put off until tomorrow, then next week—fear and procrastination win.
We understand that you cannot grow a flower in a single day: roots must take hold first, and it needs water and sun. Yet in mission, we somehow expect an instant harvest without preparing the soil.
A strong example of such consistent groundwork is the experience in Ukraine: for over four years, they systematically built a network of Bible instructors—investing thousands of person-hours, conducting countless training trips, and equipping nearly a thousand mentors to work with digital tools and handle objections.
The fruit of that labor is visible not in one-off campaigns, but in how serious projects were able to take root and thrive on that prepared soil—from launching a Digital Evangelism Center in partnership with AWR and the Hope 365 online support service to large-scale OneVoice27 trainings.
Once the infrastructure is in place, any new initiative in that territory works many times easier because there are people in the churches ready to catch and care for newcomers.
3. Fragmented Platforms and "Politics" Instead of Synergy
As a global church, we still lack a single, standardized toolkit that a local congregation can implement in a couple of days—complete with a ready-to-use mentor dashboard, clear training, and a starter budget for local ads.
Instead, Adventism has produced more than a dozen disconnected Bible schools. Over the years, we have seen and launched all kinds of versions—for Hope Channel, in Ukraine, successive generations of AWR schools, Stimme der Hoffnung projects, and Brazilian and Australian platforms.
Yet not one of them fully accounts for the entire end-to-end journey "from ad click to local church." Internal politics only compound the issue: almost every year, a new initiative rolls out, and all resources get pulled toward the latest format—even in countries where a working system is already established.
From Competition to a Unified Ecosystem
Honestly, competition governs our space far too often today instead of collaboration. Too frequently, the rule is "whoever shouts loudest" or holds the most administrative weight gets their tools promoted—even without solid evidence across the entire funnel.
Over years of operating various platforms around the world, we have already accumulated tremendous—albeit scattered—real-world experience. It is time to stop churning out isolated little tools in hopes that they will somehow assemble themselves into an ecosystem.
What we truly need to do:
Convene a digital summit of Bible schools. Sit at one table, turn off the politics, and honestly evaluate all existing solutions—their strengths, weaknesses, and failures. Today, artificial intelligence allows us to conduct a deep audit of accumulated data far faster and more objectively.
Strike a balance between standardization and localization. Form working groups to unify the core toolkit while preserving the flexibility to adapt it to the realities of specific countries and cultures.
Provide live, on-the-ground support. Every country needs a team responsible not merely for software maintenance, but for walking alongside the initiative itself, training people, and troubleshooting mistakes.
This is precisely where global structures—such as the General Conference—are called to act as a wise integrator.
As a classic saying goes, "May the best idea win." Yet in God's work, we need something greater: may the best idea not merely win, but unite the rest. I sincerely believe that with God's help, we can truly listen to one another and take steps toward genuine unity—so that not a single person searching for God online gets lost on the doorstep of our church.
In the next article, we will step down from global strategy to the local congregation level and walk through a concrete action plan: where a local church can start so that people coming from the internet don't get lost, but find living support—from their very first prayer request on social media to a core team of equipped Bible instructors.

Alex Kurenchuk
Editor, OneVoice27 Lab DeepVision Innovation
Helping ministries navigate AI, technology, and digital mission.
Missed our previous issues? Catch up here:
Can AI Autonomously Manage Your Ministry’s Social Media? We Decided to Find Out
A OneVoice editorial experiment: how to build a multi-agent "Content Factory" for Adventist projects to produce quality posts without endless hours in chat windows.
If We Want to Speak to Thousands, Why Does Our Content Look Like a Church Bulletin Board?
Searching for a format where familiar truth resonates anew: 7 creative experiments for the digital space.
